Neuroactive steroids, WIN-compounds and cholesterol share a common binding site on muscarinic acetylcholine receptors.

Endogenous neurosteroids and their synthetic analogues-neuroactive steroids-have been found to bind to muscarinic acetylcholine receptors and allosterically modulate acetylcholine binding and function. Using radioligand binding experiments we investigated their binding mode. We show that neuroactive steroids bind to two binding sites on muscarinic receptors. Their affinity for the high-affinity binding site is about 100 nM. Their affinity for the low-affinity binding site is about 10 µM. The high-affinity binding occurs at the same site as binding of steroid-based WIN-compounds that is different from the common allosteric binding site for alcuronium or gallamine that is located between the second and third extracellular loop of the receptor. This binding site is also different from the allosteric binding site for the structurally related aminosteroid-based myorelaxants pancuronium and rapacuronium. Membrane cholesterol competes with neurosteroids/neuroactive steroids binding to both high- and low-affinity binding site, indicating that both sites are oriented towards the cell membrane..

Binding of orthosteric ligands to the allosteric site of the M(2) muscarinic cholinergic receptor.

The M(2) muscarinic receptor has two topographically distinct sites: the orthosteric site and an allosteric site recognized by compounds such as gallamine. It also can exhibit cooperative effects in the binding of orthosteric ligands, presumably to the orthosteric sites within an oligomer. Such effects would be difficult to interpret, however, if those ligands also bound to the allosteric site. Monomers of the hemagglutinin (HA)- and FLAG-tagged human M(2) receptor therefore have been purified from coinfected Sf9 cells and examined for any effect of the antagonist N-methyl scopolamine or the agonist oxotremorine-M on the rate at which N-[(3)H]methyl scopolamine dissociates from the orthosteric site (k(obsd)). The predominantly monomeric status was confirmed by coimmunoprecipitation and by cross-linking with bis(sulfosuccinimidyl)suberate. Both N-methyl scopolamine and oxotremorine-M acted in a cooperative manner to decrease k(obsd) by 4.5- and 9.1-fold, respectively; the corresponding estimates of affinity (log K(L)) are -2.55 +/- 0.13 and -2.29 +/- 0.14. Gallamine and the allosteric ligand obidoxime decreased k(obsd) by more than 100-fold (log K(L) = -4.12 +/- 0.04) and by only 1.1-fold (log K(L) = -1.73 +/- 0.91), respectively. Obidoxime reversed the effect of N-methyl scopolamine, oxotremorine-M, and gallamine in a manner that could be described by a model in which all four ligands compete for a common allosteric site. Ligands generally assumed to be exclusively orthosteric therefore can act at the allosteric site of the M(2) receptor, albeit at comparatively high concentrations.

The impact of orthosteric radioligand depletion on the quantification of allosteric modulator interactions.

Radioligand binding assays remain a common method for quantifying the effects of allosteric modulators at G protein-coupled receptors. The allosteric ternary complex model (ATCM) is the simplest model applied to derive estimates of modulator affinity (K(B)) and cooperativity (alpha), which are necessary for understanding structure-activity relationships. However, the increasing drive toward assay miniaturization in modern drug discovery may lead to conditions where appreciable ligand depletion occurs in the assay. Theoretical simulations investigating the impact of orthosteric radioligand depletion on the estimation of ATCM parameters revealed the following. 1) For allosteric inhibitors, application of the standard ATCM to data obtained under depletion conditions leads to an underestimation of pK(B) and an overestimation of log alpha. 2) For allosteric enhancers, the opposite was noted, but not always; the nonlinear regression algorithm is more likely to struggle to converge to a satisfactory solution of (nondepletion) ATCM parameters in this situation. 3) Application of a novel ATCM that explicitly incorporates orthosteric ligand depletion will yield more reliable model estimates, provided the degree of depletion is not high (< approximately 50%). Subsequent experiments investigated the interaction between [3H]N-methylscopolamine and the allosteric enhancer, alcuronium, or inhibitor, gallamine, in the presence of increasing concentrations of M(2) muscarinic acetylcholine receptor and showed that application of an ATCM that explicitly incorporates radioligand depletion can indeed give more robust estimates of modulator affinity and cooperativity estimates than the standard model. These results have important implications for the quantification of allosteric modulator actions in binding-based discovery assays.

Two-state models and the analysis of the allosteric effect of gallamine at the M2 muscarinic receptor.

We measured the influence of gallamine on the functional responses and binding properties of selected agonists at the M(2) muscarinic receptor and analyzed the data within the context of the allosteric ternary complex model. Our analysis showed that gallamine modified agonist affinity without influencing efficacy. To explain this behavior, we investigated the allosteric ternary complex model at a deeper level of analysis to assess allosterism in terms of the differential affinity of gallamine for ground and active states of the receptor. Our simulations showed that two-state models based on a single orthosteric site for the agonist linked to an allosteric site for gallamine could not account for affinity-only modulation, even if multiple conformations of ground and active states were considered. We also expanded the tandem two-site model (J Biol Chem 275:18836-18844, 2000) within the context of the allosteric ternary complex model and analyzed the resulting hybrid model at the level of receptor states. This model posits that the agonist first binds to a relay site and then shuttles to the activation site to turn on the receptor. If it is assumed that allosterism occurs at the relay site and not the activation site, then this model can account for affinity-only modulation in a manner consistent with the allosteric ternary complex model.

Mutational disruption of a conserved disulfide bond in muscarinic acetylcholine receptors attenuates positive homotropic cooperativity between multiple allosteric sites and has subtype-dependent effects on the affinities of muscarinic allosteric ligands.

The 2nd outer loop (o2) of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors (mAChRs) contains a highly conserved cysteine residue that is believed to participate in a disulfide bond and is flanked on either side by epitopes that are critical to the binding of many muscarinic allosteric modulators. We determined the allosteric binding parameters of the modulators gallamine, W84, and tetrahydroaminoacridine (THA) at M2 and M3 mAChRs in which these cysteine residues had been mutated to alanines. THA is known to bind to mAChRs with a strong positive homotropic cooperativity (a Hill slope of approximately 2) that implies that it must interact with multiple allosteric sites. The disulfide cysteine mutations in M2 receptors reduced the allosteric potencies of the tested modulators as if the critical adjacent residue (Tyr177) itself had been mutated. However, in M3 receptors, the disulfide cysteine mutations had no effect on the potencies of gallamine or W84 and even increased the potency of THA. It was most interesting that the strong, positive, homotropic interactions of THA at both M2 and M3 receptors were markedly reduced by the cysteine mutations. In addition, gallamine also displayed positive homotropic cooperativity in its interactions with M3 receptors (but not M2 receptors), and this cooperativity was not evident in the cysteine mutants. Thus, it seems that these cysteine residues play a role in linking cooperating allosteric sites, although it is not currently possible to say whether these multiple sites lie within one receptor or on two linked receptors of a dimer or higher order oligomer.

Allosteric interactions with muscarinic acetylcholine receptors: complex role of the conserved tryptophan M2422Trp in a critical cluster of amino acids for baseline affinity, subtype selectivity, and cooperativity.

In general, the M2 subtype of muscarinic acetylcholine receptors has the highest sensitivity for allosteric modulators and the M5 subtype the lowest. The M2/M5 selectivity of some structurally diverse allosteric agents is known to be completely explained by M2 177Tyr and M2 423Thr in receptors whose orthosteric site is occupied by the conventional ligand N-methylscopolamine (NMS). This study explored the role of the conserved M2 422Trp and the adjacent M2 423Thr in the binding of alkane-bisammonio type modulators, gallamine, and diallylcaracurine V. Experiments were performed with human M2 or M5 receptors or mutants thereof. It was found that M2 422Trp and M2 423Thr independently influenced allosteric agent binding. The presence of M2 423Thr may enhance the affinity of binding, depending on the allosteric agent, either directly or indirectly (by avoiding sterical hindrance through its M5 counterpart 478His). Replacement of M2 422Trp and of the corresponding M5 477Trp by alanine revealed a pronounced contribution of these epitopes to subtype independent baseline affinity in NMS-bound and NMS-free receptors for all agents except diallylcaracurine V. In a few instances, this tryptophan also influenced cooperativity and subtype selectivity. Docking simulations using a three-dimensional M2 receptor model revealed that the aromatic rings of M2 177Tyr and M2 422Trp, in a concerted action, might fix one of the aromatic moieties of alkane-bisammonio compounds between them. Thus, M2 422Trp and the spatially adjacent M2 177Tyr, as well as M2 423Thr, form a cluster of amino acids within the allosteric binding cleft that is pivotal for both M2/M5 subtype selectivity and baseline affinity of allosteric agents.

Critical amino acid residues of the common allosteric site on the M2 muscarinic acetylcholine receptor: more similarities than differences between the structurally divergent agents gallamine and bis(ammonio)alkane-type hexamethylene-bis-[dimethyl-(3-phthalimidopropyl)ammonium]dibromide.

The structurally divergent agents gallamine and hexamethylene-bis-[dimethyl-(3-phthalimidopropyl)ammonium]dibromide (W84) are known to interact competitively at a common allosteric site on muscarinic receptors. Previous studies reported that the M2 selectivity of gallamine depended largely on the EDGE (172-175) sequence in the second outer loop (o2) and on 419Asn near the junction of o3 and the seventh transmembrane domain (TM7), whereas the selectivity of W84 depended on nearby residues 177Tyr and 423Thr. However, it has so far proven difficult to confer the high sensitivity for allosteric modulation of the M2 subtype onto the weakly sensitive M5 subtype by substituting these key residues. We now have found that M2 423Thr, not 419Asn, is the dominant residue in the o3/TM7 region for gallamine's high potency, although 419Asn can substitute for 423Thr in some contexts; in contrast, the presence of 419Asn reduces the potency of W84 in every context we have studied. In addition, the orientation of 177Tyr is crucial to high sensitivity toward W84, and it seems that the proline residue at position 179 in M5 (corresponding to M2 172Glu) may interfere with that orientation. Consistent with these observations, a mutant M5 receptor with these three key mutations, M5P179E, Q184Y, and H478T, showed dramatically increased sensitivity for W84 (>100-fold), compared with the wild-type M5 receptor. This same mutant receptor approached M2 sensitivity toward gallamine. Thus, gallamine and W84 derive high potency from the same receptor domains (epitopes in o2 and near the junction between o3 and TM7), even though these allosteric agents have quite different structures.

Modes of allosteric interactions with free and [3H]N-methylscopolamine-occupied muscarinic M2 receptors as deduced from buffer-dependent potency shifts.

Muscarinic M2 acetylcholine receptors contain an allosteric site that is probably located at the entrance of the ligand binding pocket above the orthosteric binding site. With the orthosteric area not occupied, allosteric agents might gain access to this site. The interaction of allosteric agents with orthoster-occupied receptors is known to depend on the buffer conditions in an alloster-specific fashion. Utilizing the buffer-dependent potency shift as an indicator, we aimed to find out for two rod-like shaped and flexible allosteric agents whether or not there is evidence for a switch in the site of attachment in free compared with [3H]N-methylscopolamine ([3H]NMS)-occupied porcine heart M2 receptors. These agents are the bispyridinium compounds WDuo3 (1,3-bis[4-(phthalimidomethoxyimino-methyl)-pyridinium-1-yl] propane dibromide) and Duo3 (4,4'-bis-[(2,6-dichloro-benzyloxy-imino)-methyl]-1,1'-propane-1,3-diyl-bis-pyridinium dibromide). The prototype allosteric agents gallamine and alcuronium were included. Inhibition of [3H]NMS association was taken to reflect alloster interaction with free receptors, inhibition of [3H]NMS dissociation indicated binding to [3H]NMS-occupied receptors. In Na,K,Pi buffer (4 mM Na2HPO4, 1 mM KH2PO4, pH 7.4 at 23 degrees C) compared with Mg,Tris,Cl,Pi buffer (45 mM Tris-HCl, 2.6 mM MgHPO4, pH 7.3 at 37 degrees C) WDuo3 underwent the same loss of potency for the interaction with either free or [3H]NMS-liganded receptors. The loss of potency was quantified by a potency ratio (PR), i.e. the ratio between the concentrations of the modulator leading to a half-maximal delay of [3H]NMS association or dissociation, respectively, in Mg,Tris,Cl,Pi compared with Na,K,Pi. For WDuo3 the ratios were PRass=27 and PRdiss=22, respectively. For Duo3, the interaction with free and [3H]NMS-occupied receptors only slightly depended on the composition of the incubation medium: PRass=1.3, PRdiss=2.8. In contrast to the other agents, the concentration-effect curves of which had slope factors nH not different from unity, the curves of Duo3 were steep (nH about -1.6). For alcuronium the shift factors amounted to PRass=29 and PRdiss=25, for gallamine to PRass=216 and PRdiss=159. In conclusion, there was a wide variation between the allosteric agents with regard to the respective buffer dependence of action. Yet, for a given allosteric agent, the interaction with either free or [3H]NMS-occupied receptors was always characterized by the same buffer-dependent shift. Thus, even the applied rod-shaped allosteric agents do not appear to switch to the orthosteric site in free compared with orthoster-occupied M2 receptors.

Muscarinic M(2) receptors are not primarily involved in the contraction of guinea-pig gallbladder smooth muscle.

The presence of M(1)-M(4) receptors in guinea-pig gallbladder smooth muscle cells has been reported recently. The majority of these receptors are said to be of M(2) subtype. However, there are controversial reports about the functional muscarinic receptors that mediate contraction in this tissue. Similar to gallbladder, it was claimed that M(4) receptors mediate guinea-pig uterine contractions, but these receptors have appeared to be of M(2) subtypes later. Therefore, the antagonistic affinities of three M(2)-selective muscarinic antagonists were determined in contraction and radioligand binding experiments in guinea-pig gallbladder in the present study. The antagonistic affinity values (p K(i)) of gallamine, tripitramine and imperialine were as follows, respectively: 6.28+/-0.15, 8.65+/-0.10 and 6.55+/-0.07 against 0.250 n m [(3)H]QNB binding. All three antagonists displaced the concentration- response curves to carbachol to the right in parallel without affecting the maximum responses. The p A(2) values obtained from constrained Schild plots (-log K(B)) were 4.14+/-0.18 for gallamine, 6.79+/-0.09 for tripitramine, and 7.02+/-0.09 for imperialine. The antagonistic affinity values of gallamine, tripitramine and imperialine for M(2) receptors are reported to be 6. 3, 9.6, 7.7, respectively. The p A(2) values obtained in this study clearly indicate that the primary muscarinic receptors involved in carbachol-induced guinea-pig gallbladder contraction are not of M(2) subtype. The poor correlation between the antagonistic affinity values of these antagonists obtained at radioligand binding (p K(i)) and contraction (p A(2)) experiments also support the conclusion that the majority of muscarinic receptors which have been reported to be of M(2) do not mediate the contractile responses.

Using a radioalloster to test predictions of the cooperativity model for gallamine binding to the allosteric site of muscarinic acetylcholine M(2) receptors.

The muscarinic M(2) receptor contains an orthosteric and an allosteric site. Binding of an allosteric agent may induce a shift alpha of the equilibrium dissociation constant K(D) of a radioligand for the orthosteric site. According to the cooperativity model, the K(A) of alloster binding is expected to be shifted to an identical extent depending on whether the orthosteric site is occupied by the orthoster or not. Here, the novel radioalloster [(3)H]dimethyl-W84 (N,N'-bis[3-(1,3-dihydro-1, 3-dioxo-4-methyl-2H-isoindol-2-yl)propyl]-N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-1, 6-hexanediaminium diiodide) was applied to directly measure the K(A) shift induced for the prototype allosteric modulator gallamine by binding of N-methylscopolamine (NMS) to the orthosteric site of porcine heart M(2) receptors (4 mM Na(2)HPO(4), 1 mM KH(2)PO(4), pH 7.4; 23 degrees C; data are means +/- S.E.). First, in the common way, the concentration-dependent inhibition by gallamine of [(3)H]NMS equilibrium binding was measured and analyzed using the cooperativity model, which yielded for the affinity of gallamine binding at free receptors a pK(A)= 8.35 +/- 0.09 and a cooperativity factor alpha = 46 (n = 5). The dissociation constant for gallamine binding at NMS-occupied receptors was predicted as p(alpha. K(A)) = 6.69. Labeling of the allosteric site by [(3)H]dimethyl-W84 allowed the measure of competitive displacement curves for gallamine. The K(i) for gallamine at free receptors amounted to pK(i,-NMS) = 8.27 +/- 0.39 (n = 5), which is in line with the prediction of the cooperativtiy model. In the presence of 1 microM NMS, to occupy the orthosteric site, gallamine displaced [(3)H]dimethyl-W84 with pK(i, +NMS) = 6.60 +/- 0.19 (n = 3). Thus, the NMS-induced pK(i) shift amounted to 47, which matches the predicted value of alpha = 46. These results validate the cooperativity model.

The influence of peripheral site ligands on the reaction of symmetric and chiral organophosphates with wildtype and mutant acetylcholinesterases.

The rates of inhibition of mouse acetylcholinesterase (AChE) (EC 3.1.1.7) by paraoxon, haloxon, DDVP, and enantiomers of neutral alkyl methylphosphonyl thioates and cationic alkyl methylphosphonyl thiocholines were measured in the presence and absence of AChE peripheral site inhibitors: gallamine, D-tubocurarine, propidium, atropine and derivatives of coumarin. All ligands, except the coumarins, at submillimolar concentrations enhanced the rates of inhibition by neutral organophosphorus compounds (OPs) while inhibition rates by cationic OPs were slowed down. When peripheral site ligand concentrations extended to millimolar, the extent of the enhancement decreased creating a bell shaped activation profile. Analysis of inhibition by DDVP and haloxon revealed that peripheral site inhibitors increased the second order reaction rates by increasing maximal rates of phosphylation.

Peripheral binding site is involved in the neurotrophic activity of acetylcholinesterase.

Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) catalyses the hydrolysis of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine and it has been implicated in several non-cholinergic actions, including neurite outgrowth and amyloid formation. We have studied the trophic function of brain AChE on neuronal cell metabolism and proliferation as well as the enzyme domain involved in such effects. Low AChE concentrations (0.1-2.5 nM) stimulated neurite outgrowth and induced cell proliferation as measured by MTT reduction and [3H]thymidine incorporation. The action of AChE was not affected by edrophonium and tacrine both active site inhibitors, but it was abolished by propidium and gallamine, two peripheral anionic binding site (PAS) ligands. We conclude that the PAS domain of AChE is involved in the neurotrophic activity of the enzyme.

Use of antimuscarinic toxins to facilitate studies of striatal m4 muscarinic receptors.

Striatal m4 muscarinic receptors are important because their blockade controls movement, and they are preferentially located on striatal neurons that project to the internal globus pallidus. The following studies were performed in vitro to provide a basis for using antimuscarinic toxins to study the effects of selective m4 blockade on movement in vivo. Because m4-toxin has limited selectivity alone (102-fold higher affinity for m4 than m1 receptors), m1-toxin was used first to occlude m1 receptors selectively, fully and irreversibly. It blocked 42% of the sites for 1.0 nM 3H-N-methylscopolamine in rat striatal membranes and 43% in sections of cat striatum. m4-Toxin (>500-fold higher affinity for m4 than m2, m3 or m5 receptors) blocked 88% of the residual, non-m1 sites in membranes, showing 64 pmol m4 receptors/g tissue. In comparison, AFDX-116, biperiden, clozapine, gallamine, hexahydrodifenidol, himbacine, R(+)hyoscyamine, methoctramine, pirenzepine, silahexocyclium, trihexyphenidyl and tripitramine did not distinguish m4 from other non-m1 receptors. 3H-Pirenzepine dissociated twice as rapidly from non-m1 as m1 receptors. Autoradiography was used to test the idea that m4 receptors are localized preferentially in the striosomes of the cat striatum. Non-m1 receptors were distributed equally in striosomes and matrix, indicating that striatal neurons with m4 receptors are in both compartments. Thus m1-toxin facilitates studies of m4 receptors by occluding m1 receptors, and m4-toxin is a selective antagonist for residual m4 receptors.

Structural diversity among subtypes of small-conductance Ca2+-activated potassium channels.

125I-Apamin and photolabile derivatives of the toxin have been used to investigate the binding properties and subunit composition of small conductance Ca2+-activated potassium channels (SK(Ca) channels) expressed on plasma membranes from rat brain, rabbit liver, or rat pheochromocytoma (PC12) cells. On all preparations, 125I-apamin recognized single classes of acceptor binding sites with similar high affinity (Kd approximately 3-6 pM). Gallamine, however, was found to readily discriminate between 125I-apamin acceptors present in these preparations, showing a maximal approx nine-fold difference in affinity for acceptors expressed by rabbit liver or PC12 cells. Affinity-labeling patterns revealed the expression of different hetero-oligomeric combinations of high (86 or 59 kDa) and low (33 or 30 kDa) molecular mass 125I-apamin-binding polypeptides, consistent with pharmacological differences. Alternative expression of either 86- or 59-kDa polypeptides appeared to be the most important factor influencing gallamine's affinity for SK(Ca) channel subtypes. Both high- and low-molecular-mass polypeptides are integral membrane proteins, the latter being glycosylated in a tissue-specific manner.

Application of an allosteric ternary complex model to the technique of pharmacological resultant analysis.

A simple ternary complex model of drug-receptor interaction has been used to extend the procedure of pharmacological resultant analysis, enabling the quantitation of interactions between allosteric modulators and orthosteric antagonists. Equations derived in the theoretical treatment were used to analyse functional data for the interaction between the allosteric modulator gallamine and the orthosteric antagonist scopolamine, with oxotremorine as the agonist, at rat tracheal muscarinic acetylcholine receptors. Quantitative estimates of the affinity of gallamine for the allosteric site (pKz = 4.7) and the extent of negative, heterotropic co-operativity between gallamine and scopolamine (alpha' = 13.1) were obtained. Furthermore, an alternative direct, model-fitting approach, that does not rely on the determination of concentration ratios, was also developed, and yielded similar results. It is suggested that the approach presented in this paper is useful for quantifying interactions between orthosteric antagonists and allosteric modulators, particularly when the extent of co-operativity is low or the modulators possess multiple pharmacological properties, or both.

Competition between positive and negative allosteric effectors on muscarinic receptors.

Alcuronium allosterically increases the affinity of cardiac muscarinic receptors for methyl-N-scopolamine (NMS), whereas gallamine has the opposite effect. We discovered that strychnine also increases the affinity of muscarinic receptors in rat heart atria for NMS. It is not known whether the positive and the negative allosteric effectors bind to the same binding site. To investigate this question, we elaborated on a theoretical model predicting changes in the binding of a classic radiolabeled ligand occurring in the presence of a positive and a negative allosteric effector that compete for the allosteric binding site. The model is based on data obtained at equilibrium and avoids uncertainties associated with the use of nonequilibrium methods for the evaluation of interactions between allosteric ligands. We examined changes in the binding of [3H]NMS to membranes of rat heart atria exposed to various concentrations of a positive allosteric effector (alcuronium or strychnine) and of a negative allosteric effector (gallamine) simultaneously. The binding data obtained were in perfect agreement with the model assuming competition between gallamine and alcuronium and gallamine and strychnine, strongly suggesting that these positive and negative allosteric effectors bind to identical or overlapping sites.

Probing of the location of the allosteric site on m1 muscarinic receptors by site-directed mutagenesis.

In an attempt to locate the allosteric site on muscarinic receptors to which gallamine binds, 21 residues in the putative external loops and loop/transmembrane helix interfaces have been mutated to alanine. These residues are conserved in mammalian m1-m5 receptors. All mutant receptors can be expressed in COS-7 cells at high levels and appear to be functional, in that acetylcholine binding is sensitive to GTP. The gallamine binding site does not appear to involve the first, second, and most of the third extracellular loops. Tryptophan-400 and -101 inhibit gallamine binding when mutated to alanine or to phenylalanine and may form part of the allosteric site. Several mutations also affect antagonist binding. Surprisingly, tryptophan-91, a residue conserved in monoamine and peptide receptors, is important for antagonist binding. This residue, present in the middle of the first extracellular loop, may have a structural role in many G protein-coupled receptors. Antagonist binding is also affected by mutations of tryptophan-101 and tyrosine-404 to alanine or phenylalanine. In a helical wheel model, trytophan-101 and tyrosine-404, in conjunction with serine-78, aspartate-105, and tyrosine-408, form a cluster of residues that have been reported to affect antagonist binding when mutated, and they may therefore be part of the antagonist binding site. It is suggested that the allosteric site may be located close to and just extracellular to the antagonist binding site. The binding of methoctramine, an antagonist with allosteric properties, is not substantially affected by mutations at tryptophan-91, -101, and -400 and tyrosine-404, and thus these amino acids are not important for its binding. The binding of himbacine, another antagonist with allosteric properties, is affected by these mutations but in a manner different from that of gallamine or competitive antagonists. It has not been possible to determine whether methoctramine and himbacine bind exclusively to the allosteric site or to both the competitive site and the allosteric site.

Competitive antagonists bridge the alpha-gamma subunit interface of the acetylcholine receptor through quaternary ammonium-aromatic interactions.

We recently demonstrated that conserved tyrosines Tyr198 of the alpha subunit and Tyr117 of the gamma subunit of the acetylcholine receptor stabilize binding of the curariform antagonist dimethyl-d-tubocurarine (DMT). To test the hypothesis that DMT interacts directly with these tyrosines, and therefore bridges the alpha-gamma subunit interface, we introduced point mutations into these key positions and expressed one or both mutant subunits in alpha 2 beta gamma 2 acetylcholine receptors in 293 HEK cells. Binding of DMT, measured by competition against the initial rate of 125I-alpha-bungarotoxin binding, shows high affinity for aromatic mutations, reduced affinity for polar mutations, and lowest affinity for arginine mutations. Similar side chain dependences were observed for both Tyr alpha 198 and Tyr gamma 117, indicating interaction of these residues with two symmetrical chemical groups in DMT. Two more bisquaternary antagonists, pancuronium and gallamine, show side chain dependences similar to that of DMT, indicating that the primary stabilizing interactions are aromatic-quaternary in both subunits. For the rigid ligands DMT and pancuronium, co-expressing mutant alpha and gamma subunits revealed independent contributions by each determinant, but strict independence was not observed for the flexible ligand gallamine. The free energy contributed by each aromatic-quaternary interaction was estimated to be 2-4 kcal/mol, as determined from the free energy difference between aromatic and alkyl hydroxyl mutations. Our results suggest that bis-quaternary competitive antagonists bridge the alpha-gamma subunit interface by fitting into a pocket bounded by tyrosines at positions 198 of the alpha subunit and 117 of the gamma subunit.

Differential effects of "peripheral" site ligands on Torpedo and chicken acetylcholinesterase.

Comparison of the effect of three 'peripheral' site ligands, propidium, d-tubocurarine, and gallamine, on acetylcholinesterase (acetylcholine hydrolase; EC 3.1.1.7) of Torpedo and chicken shows that all three are substantially more effective inhibitors of the Torpedo enzyme than of the chicken enzyme. In contrast, edrophonium, which is directed to the "anionic" subsite of the active site, inhibits the chicken and Torpedo enzymes equally effectively. Two bisquaternary ligands, decamethonium and 1,5-bis(4-allydimethylammoniumphenyl)pentan-3-one dibromide, which are believed to bridge the anionic subsite of the active site and the "peripheral" anionic site, are much weaker inhibitors of the chicken enzyme than of Torpedo acetylcholinesterase, whereas the shorter bisquaternary ligand hexamethonium inhibits the two enzymes similarly. The concentration dependence of activity towards the natural substrate acetylcholine is almost identical for the two enzymes, whereas substrate inhibition of chicken acetylcholinesterase is somewhat weaker than that of the Torpedo enzyme. The experimental data can be rationalized on the basis of the three-dimensional structure of the Torpedo enzyme and alignment of the chicken and Torpedo sequences; it is suggested that the absence, in the chicken enzyme, of two aromatic residues, Tyr-70 and Trp-279, that contribute to the peripheral site of Torpedo acetylcholinesterase is responsible for the differential effects of peripheral site ligands on the two enzymes.

Selective enhancement of the interaction of curare with the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor.

Alteration of the ligand-binding domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor through site-directed mutagenesis offers a powerful approach to the elucidation of structure-function relations in the receptor. Several conserved tyrosine residues in the large extracellular amino terminus of the alpha subunit of the receptor have been implicated by both chemical labeling and mutagenesis studies as playing an important role in the interaction of acetylcholine with the receptor. We and others have previously shown that substitution of phenylalanine for tyrosine at position 198 of the alpha subunit (alpha Y198F) leads to a rightward shift in the dose-response curve for acetylcholine-elicited currents. We have further investigated this particular mutation by examining the interaction of the competitive antagonist d-tubocurarine (curare) with the receptor. In contrast to the effect on the interaction of agonists with the receptor, this mutation leads to a marked increase in the affinity of the receptor for curare. Furthermore, this enhancement in affinity is selective for curare and is not seen with other competitive antagonists (pancuronium, beta-erythroidine, and gallamine). Examination of the structures of these competitive antagonists leads to the proposal that this enhancement is due to the formation of an aromatic-aromatic interaction between the phenylalanine ring at position alpha 198 in the mutant and one of the aromatic rings of curare and that this can provide information about the spatial arrangement of this residue in the binding site.